I’ve been a Slashdot reader, member, and occasional poster for years now, at least since 2000-ish, possibly earlier. Slashdot, a.k.a. /., as many of you probably know, is one of the ‘premier’ geek news sites. Hundreds of thousands of techies, geeks, trolls and cubicle philosophers visit it every day and shoot the shit on the comment sections of the news articles. Dozens of amusing, interesting, bizarre, or just vaguely noteworthy links to articles are posted day after day. Nerdvana, right? Unfortunately, not so much. For a good long while now, /. has been going downhill. The quality of news posts seems to be getting worse and worse. Pseudo-science stories are uncritically and unapologetically posted on the front page. Dupes, stories that have been previously posted, are a daily occurrence. But I can live with all that. The thing that spooked me away from Slashdot, maybe for good, is the comments section.
Once upon a time, the comments section of a /. story was a cool place to be: you were surrounded by fellow geeks who were interested in technology, with weird senses of humor, lots of technical knowledge, and decent vocabularies. But over time, that has changed. The average /. comment area is now plagued with trolls, morons who don’t know a thing about what the article is even about but still feel the need to tell everyone why it won’t work, and attacking each other incessantly over real or imagined slights. Not even browsing the comments at +5 helps: for every comment with actual intelligent content that gets modded ‘+5, Interesting’, there’s 10 that are nothing but a rephrasing of the actual text of the article itself that get modded ‘+5, Insightful’. Slashdot has collapsed under the weight of its own, increasingly idiotic, user base.
Other sites have tried to form ‘alternate /.’s’, with varying degrees of success. Kuro5hin, a.k.a. K5, is one of the better known, with a wider range of topics than just tech, a slightly better-behaved user base, and generally better thought-through articles. Sadly, K5 can’t hope to match the community size of something like /., and the more stringent submission procedures for stories mean that it can sometimes be days before a good article makes it to the front page. Other /. alternatives tend to suffer from similar problems.
So, now that I’ve decided to dump Slashdot, and have pointed out that most alternatives suck, what am I going to do to get my daily technology news fix? The answer, my friends, is Digg. Digg.com is a new technology news site that’s the brainchild of Kevin Rose and Alex Albrecht, formerly of the now-defunct, but never forgotten, TechTV, and now currently doing the excellent online show, Systm. It combines the power of social bookmarking, RSS, and social networking (buzzword bingo!) to create something fairly unique that, so far, actually works. I highly reccommend you check out the site, but in a nutshell, Digg allows you to create an account and ‘digg’ sotries you are interested in. When you digg a story, it gets added to your personal list, where it’s already categorized and ready to search. Thus, by digging stories and articles you are interested in, you create a personal bookmark set, organized by category, of things that interest you, which you can access from anywhere. You can keep yourself to the main page, or you can view all submitted articles, and digg the ones you’re interested in there. When an article gets enough diggs, it gets bumped to the main page, so only things that the community is interested in show up.
Of course, that’s not all of it. Digg also has commenting capabilities on the articles, and as you notice users who consistently make interesting,intelligent comments, you can add those people as friends. This allows you to view what articles they have dugg, which can bring articles that you might have otherwise have missed to your attention, or bring further attention to an article that you ignored before. As you add more friends, Digg allows you to view a combined list of articles dugg by all your friends. This is supremely cool: You can view news and links selected by people you have personally selected as trustworthy.
Your dugg articles are immeidately made available as RSS feeds, as are those of your friends, so you can subscribe not only to the main Digg page, but also the the dugg articles from your friends, display them on your own site, take them with you on an RSS reader, do whatever you want. Digg even makes it easy to post artciles and article links to your personal blog, with a ‘blog this’ link on all articles that interfaces directly with your blog (you probably already noticed a couple of articles from Digg that I posted up over the weekend).
Overall, Digg.com seems to work perfectly. How clean and useful the comments section will be, remains to be seen as more and more people hit up Digg, but the ability to add friends and view their diggs might be what saves it: you can filter out the idiots a lot easier. Go check it out, you just might forget all about /. for good. 